Igor Barani

How children learn mathematics · Part 4 of 4

When should a teacher show a child how to add fractions?

A child adds a half and a third and gets less than a half.

Igor Barani · · 27 min read

Contents
  1. In short
  2. 01The question to which two fifths is right
  3. 02What the teacher can give away
  4. 03Two good beginnings for the same lesson
  5. 04An error on the record since 1978
  6. 05The check is already in the standard
  7. 06One sum, three textbooks
  8. 07Who chose the book
  9. 08The closest experiment used pizza
  10. 09The purple pen
  11. 10What the average leaves out
  12. 11The case for showing first
  13. 12Check
  14. Keep
  15. Sources

A child writes 1/2 + 1/3 = 2/5. What would you say next?

I would cover the answer with my hand. Put a strip of paper on the table and call its length one. Mark halfway. “If you start here and add a third of this strip, which way will you go?” A child can move a finger to the right without knowing where to stop. Now uncover the answer. Two fifths ends to the left of the finger’s starting place. Something has gone wrong, and the child can be the first to notice.

That leaves the teacher with a deci­sion. I would let the child try another mark if the child can use the half to judge the last one. If the child cannot yet find the half, keeps changing which strip counts as one, or would plainly welcome a demon­stra­tion after several unsuc­cessful tries, I would show the missing step. Then I would hand back the pencil. I have more con­fi­dence in the ques­tion than in my rule for acting on the answer. The ques­tion reveals which part of the cal­cu­la­tion the child can already check. The research gives a much less certain answer about which child learns more by going first. For chil­dren of this age the exper­i­ments lean toward showing first, and no trial has tested my rule. Ask where the sum must land before anyone com­putes. After showing the common unit, leave the next piece for the child to place.

1/202/51
Slide the figure sideways to see all of it.
Figure 1Two fifths can be ruled out before the sum is known. The short marks divide one whole into fifths. Constructed from the example.

The check behind that ques­tion has been printed in the Common Core stan­dards since 2010.1 The deci­sion that follows it has usually been made before the teacher sits down, by the text­book. Of three grade 5 pro­grams exam­ined here, two set this same sum, and the third sets 2/3 + 1/2 and says its stu­dents have met 1/2 + 1/3. One lets chil­dren try first and builds on their attempts. Another has part­ners say whether a half and a fourth can be added, then leads the class through folding before anyone works a sum. The third has chil­dren try, then explains. In the lessons read here, only one asks where the sum must land before it teaches the method. All three hold the same rating from the same independent reviewer, which says it rates mate­rials “as they’re designed, not as imple­mented”.2,3,4,5 I write and will sell ele­men­tary math­e­matics books for fam­i­lies and schools, an interest set out below with the three programs.

The question to which two fifths is right

Suppose a child takes two shots at a basket and makes one. Later the child takes three shots and makes one. What frac­tion of the day’s shots went in? Two out of five. Adding the two top numbers and the two bottom numbers is exactly the right thing to do with this record. The record holds two baskets and five attempts.

Now pour half a cup of water into a bowl. Add a third of the same cup. The cup has stayed on the counter, the same size all along. The water in the bowl has risen. Calling the result two fifths of a cup would ask the child to believe there is less water after the second pour.

The dif­fer­ence is in what gets com­bined. In the game, two sets of attempts become a larger set, and the ques­tion asks for the share of that larger set that suc­ceeded. In the bowl, two amounts are added and mea­sured with the orig­inal cup. The marks on the page tell me which cal­cu­la­tion the child did. They tell me little about whether the child was counting pieces, bor­rowing a rule, or writing some­thing to get an adult to move on. I would save the bas­ket­ball ques­tion for after the cup is secure. It is a good ques­tion for a teacher to have in mind before declaring that one must never add denominators.

Researchers have doc­u­mented the pull of whole-number arith­metic on frac­tion prob­lems. They have also doc­u­mented how vari­able an indi­vidual child’s answers can be. In a study pub­lished online in August 2026, Sabrina Di Lonardo Burr and col­leagues recruited 1,055 chil­dren in 24 class­rooms in Jinan, China. They assessed frac­tion knowl­edge four times across grades four and five. Understanding a shaded part of a whole tended to settle earlier. Judgments about size and about the numbers between two frac­tions shifted more often. Some chil­dren who answered cor­rectly on one occa­sion returned to a whole-number response later. One answer can guide the next ques­tion. It is a poor basis for giving a child a mathematical identity.6,7

A second reason calls for care with the opening. A child may know that adding a pos­i­tive length carries the finger forward and still be unable to place 2/5. That child has already shown some­thing about addi­tion. Offer a second copy of the whole, folded into five equal parts. Ask the child to lay two of those parts against the half. A child who now rejects the answer needed help com­paring frac­tions. Starting the entire addi­tion lesson again would have obscured the distinction.

What the teacher can give away

Lay three paper strips of equal length on the table. Leave one whole. Fold another in half and a third into thirds. Take one half and one third, put the half at the left end of the whole and slide the third up against it. The join and the far end are the two pencil marks that matter. Ask for a way of reporting the total to someone who cannot see the table.

Try thirds as a ruler. The join falls between two marks. Try halves. The join lands, but the far end does not. Now split each third of the ruler into two equal steps. Six of the little steps fill the whole. Three reach the join and two more reach the far end. Here is what the written line records.

1/2 + 1/3 = 3/6 + 2/6 = 5/6.

One whole1/21/3The piecesIn thirdsIn halvesIn sixths35
Slide the figure sideways to see all of it.
Figure 2On the sixths scale, three steps reach the join and five reach the far end. The rulers all measure the same whole. Constructed from the example.

The child has done two quite dif­ferent things in that line of arith­metic. First the child has renamed two lengths without changing either. Only then has the child added the counts of steps of one size. Ask one more ques­tion. “When the half became three sixths, what got smaller?” Each step did. The length covered by the three steps is still the half put down at the start.

Six is con­ve­nient. Twelve also works. The half covers six twelfths, the third covers four, and ten twelfths ends at the same pencil mark. A child who pro­poses twelfths has sup­plied a solu­tion. Asking for the smallest common denom­i­nator at this moment can turn a math­e­mat­i­cally suc­cessful choice into what sounds like a mistake. There will be time to dis­cover why smaller counts are easier to manage.

The whole matters even when the drawing looks con­vincing. Half of a twelve-cen­timeter strip and a third of an eigh­teen-cen­timeter strip are both six centimeters. Those lengths can cer­tainly be added. Together they make twelve centimeters, one whole of the first strip or two thirds of the second. Before saying what frac­tion of a whole the result is, someone has to choose the whole. Bare numbers such as 1/2 and 1/3 already share the unit 1. Paper, ribbons and pic­tures require the teacher to say which length stands for it. The Common Core’s grade 3 stan­dard says com­par­isons “are valid only when the two frac­tions refer to the same whole”.1

Two good beginnings for the same lesson

In one version, the teacher shows the six equal steps at once. Put the half across three sixths, write the equality under it and slide the orig­inal half on top again. Then give the child the third. “Where will this end if you start it here?” The teacher has removed the search for a unit. The child still has to pre­serve the length when the starting place moves and decide how many of the new units it covers. Put the strips away and a harder ques­tion remains. A class­mate says that turning a half into three sixths has made it three times as long. What drawing would settle that disagreement?

In the other version, the teacher puts the half and the third end to end and waits while the child tries a ruler made of thirds. The end falls between the marks. The child who folds one of those inter­vals in half has earned another turn with the pencil. A child who repeat­edly moves the marks until both pieces appear to fit needs one thing shown imme­di­ately. The size of a step stays fixed from one end of a ruler to the other. Mark the sixths on a fresh strip, cover three with the half, and leave the third for the child to place.

These ver­sions can con­verge in less than a lesson. A brief invi­ta­tion to point or draw is also pos­sible in either version. It differs con­sid­er­ably from the extended search researchers some­times call pro­duc­tive failure, in which stu­dents gen­erate solutions to a delib­er­ately unfa­miliar problem and a teacher sub­se­quently develops the formal idea. Calling every pause before an expla­na­tion “pro­duc­tive failure” would let a thirty-minute exper­i­ment take credit for a ques­tion asked in passing.8,9

My reason for the con­di­tion is what a child can do with a mark that turns out wrong. Say the child tries a ruler marked in thirds and the half ends between two marks. A child who can use the half to judge that mark reads the miss as news about thirds, and picks the next ruler for a reason. Without the check, the miss tells the child only that the adult is still waiting. No study found for this essay has tested this rea­soning, and one finding is a reason to doubt it. Robert Siegler and Hugues Lortie-Forgues write that under­standing the sizes of frac­tions “often is insuf­fi­cient” for learning to compute with them. They describe future teachers who knew the sizes well and com­puted poorly. They add that under­standing sizes “does seem to be an essen­tial com­po­nent” of improving arith­metic.10 Knowing where the half lies may be needed without being enough to let a child find the sixths.

With a class, I would ask everyone to put one mark where the half ends and indi­cate the direc­tion in which the sum must lie. I would look at the work of chil­dren who have said nothing. If several strips show a changing whole, I would model the common unit for the room. A child who finds folding dif­fi­cult can point while a partner moves the paper. Each child can then make a fresh mark after the demon­stra­tion. That second mark also lets the teacher revise a mis­taken first impression.

In an earlier note I posed a ques­tion about a six-year-old, a book­case in the hall and a gap beside a window. Would the book­case fit? A child who can already compare two widths side by side has a reason to want a length of string. The string carries one width to the place where the other is, so the two can be com­pared. The frac­tion problem has made me qualify the argu­ment I made there. A ques­tion can create a need for a tool. Whether a child can feel that need depends on what the child can already do.11

An error on the record since 1978

In 1978 the National Assessment of Educational Progress put a frac­tion sum to more than 20,000 eighth graders. Which whole number is closest to 12/13 + 7/8? The choices were 1, 2, 19, 21 and “I don’t know.” Each frac­tion is a little less than one, so the sum is a little less than two. Twenty-four percent of the stu­dents chose 2. The most common answer was 19.6

Nineteen is 12 + 7, the two top numbers. Twenty-one is 13 + 8, the two bottom numbers. The item is the child’s 2/5, set as a mul­tiple-choice ques­tion 48 years ago.

A review by Hugues Lortie-Forgues, Jing Tian and Robert Siegler reports the 1978 figures sec­ond­hand. The same review describes a later study of sixth and eighth graders adding and sub­tracting frac­tions, in which 22% of the answers treated tops and bottoms as sep­a­rate whole numbers.6

The check is already in the standard

The Common Core’s grade 5 stan­dard on adding frac­tions asks chil­dren to use bench­mark frac­tions and number sense to judge an answer. Its example is to “rec­og­nize an incor­rect result 2/5 + 1/2 = 3/7, by observing that 3/7 < 1/2”.1 Arizona’s fifth-grade stan­dards carry the same example, and give esti­ma­tion a place along­side exact addi­tion and sub­trac­tion with unlike denominators.12

A federal frac­tions guide pub­lished the same year works a near twin. A student esti­mates that 1/2 + 1/5 lies between a half and three quar­ters, then adds tops and bottoms and gets 2/7. The teacher, the guide says, can point out that “this answer cannot be right because 2/7 is less than 1/2.” The guide adds that teachers can ask for an esti­mate before stu­dents compute. It recommends the number line for estab­lishing frac­tions as numbers and recommends con­necting pro­ce­dures to their mean­ings. It rates the evi­dence for both recommenda­tions as moderate.13

These are good grounds for spending class time on the size of the answer. Neither source pre­scribes who should make the first fold. The stan­dard gives no order of teaching. The guide’s own illus­tra­tion of 1/2 + 1/3 is one in which “teachers can demon­strate” that sixths give a common denominator.13

The check, and the advice to ask for an esti­mate first, belong to those two doc­u­ments. What I add is a use for the answer. The child’s reply decides who makes the next mark. The bas­ket­ball record is the other thing I would add, because it shows the teacher the ques­tion to which the child’s answer is correct.

One sum, three textbooks

The method here means renaming both frac­tions in a common unit and adding the counts.

I am writing ele­men­tary math­e­matics books that use prob­lems of this kind. I write and will sell the With Every Reason books, ele­men­tary math­e­matics books with a kit of mate­rials, pub­lished by my company, KAGU, LLC. They are still being written and are not yet on sale. I will sell them to fam­i­lies and to schools, including through dis­trict adop­tions like those described below. My own books take the try-first side: every new idea arrives as a task the child attempts before she is told the rule. They do not leave her there. The reason and the rule follow, and if she stalls, the adult shows one worked example in the same sitting. Great Minds, which pub­lishes Eureka Math, Savvas, which pub­lishes enVision, and Kendall Hunt and Imagine Learning, which dis­tribute Illustrative Mathematics, sell to the same schools. So my interest pulls toward finding their lessons wanting, and toward which­ever answer matches my own books. I report only what the programs’ own lessons and training hand­outs, copies of them posted by others, and one independent reviewer say, each cited. I make no com­par­ison with my books. Every ques­tion I put to these lessons applies to mine. No trial has tested the order in my books either.

The teacher pages of IM K–5 Math, by Illustrative Mathematics, are posted openly by its dis­trib­utor Kendall Hunt, though some parts need a login. In grade 5, sums with unlike denom­i­na­tors arrive in Unit 6, Lesson 8. The lesson’s stated purpose is for stu­dents to add frac­tions with unlike denom­i­na­tors “in a way that makes sense to them.” One activity asks for 2/3 + 1/2. The notes tell the teacher to “Monitor for and select stu­dents” who used a number line or equiv­a­lent frac­tions, and to have them share. For a child with no strategy they supply a ques­tion, “How could you use one number line to show both of these frac­tions?”.14 In Lesson 9 stu­dents rename frac­tions and “use those equiv­a­lent frac­tions to find sums.” Its warm-up asks whether 1/2 + 1/4 = 2/4 is true. A child can reject that by size, though the notes give its purpose as “using equiv­a­lent frac­tions to add and sub­tract”.15 Lesson 10 explains why mul­ti­plying the two denom­i­na­tors always yields a common one. Its notes say stu­dents had added 1/2 + 1/3 “in a pre­vious lesson”.16 An esti­mate comes in Lesson 12, in a warm-up on 3/17 + 17/19, three lessons after the method.17

Eureka Math is pub­lished by Great Minds. The lesson read here is Module 3, Lesson 3, in Great Minds’ 2013 text as fea­tured on EngageNY, New York State’s cur­riculum site, and repro­duced with anno­ta­tions by Achieve the Core. It is not the 2015 edition that EdReports rated, nor the current Eureka Math², which was not exam­ined. The teacher asks part­ners whether one half and one fourth can be added. Then the script reads “Lead stu­dents through the process of folding,” with paper for each child, and after that, “Draw a rec­tangle model for stu­dents.” The second problem is 1/3 + 1/2. Before drawing it the teacher asks, “Do our units get bigger or smaller when we create like units? Talk to your partner.” It is nearly the ques­tion I ask about the sixths. No task in the lesson asks for an esti­mate before com­puting. Its closing dis­cus­sion com­pares fin­ished sums with a half and with one.18 The module’s over­view, dated 2014, lists Lesson 13, in which chil­dren “use frac­tion bench­mark numbers to assess rea­son­able­ness” of sums and dif­fer­ences.19 In this text, as in Illustrative Mathematics, the esti­mate follows the method.

Less of enVision Mathematics, pub­lished by Savvas, could be read, because its teacher’s edition is not posted pub­licly. What follows comes from two Savvas training hand­outs and from lesson pas­sages quoted in EdReports’ review. Every lesson begins with a problem that stu­dents work, called Solve & Share.20,21 The handout for the pre­vious edition says that in the next step the con­cepts “are made explicit through direct instruc­tion,” as the teacher guides stu­dents “through a com­pleted problem”.21 In the pas­sages EdReports quotes, Lesson 7-1, the topic’s first lesson, asks for an esti­mate. It offers three lengths, 1/2, 1/3 and 7/8 of a yard. Children are to pick, “Without finding the exact amount,” the two that come closest to a yard and a half. Lesson 7-3 adds 1/3 mile to 1/2 mile and asks whether 12 would also serve as the common denom­i­nator.4 In the lessons read, enVision is the only one of the three that asks for an esti­mate before the method.

Child triesTeacher showsMethod taughtEstimate askedIllustrative MathematicsGrade 5, Unit 6, Lessons 8–1289101112Model: strips and number lines2021 edition; EdReports rated 2021: meets expectationsEureka Math (EngageNY)Grade 5, Module 3, Lessons 3–13Not examined4–12313Model: paper folding, then a rectangleEngageNY 2013; EdReports rated 2015: meets expectationsenVision MathematicsGrade 5, Topic 7, Lessons 7-1 to 7-3Not public7-17-27-3Model: “visual models”; details not publicHandouts 2017, 2020; EdReports rated 2024: meets expectations
Slide the figure sideways to see all of it.
Figure 3One sum, three openings. Each lane follows one grade 5 program through its first lessons on adding fractions with different denominators. It marks who moves first, where the method is taught and where an estimate of the sum is asked. The estimate sits after the method in two programs and before it in the third. Illustrative Mathematics and Eureka Math are drawn from publicly posted copies of their lesson pages. Eureka beyond Lesson 3 is drawn from its module overview, with Lessons 4 to 12 not examined. The enVision lane rests on Savvas training handouts and on passages quoted by EdReports.

EdReports is an independent reviewer whose judg­ments, by one account, influ­ence adop­tion deci­sions in many states.22 It rates the grade 5 mate­rials of all three pro­grams “Meets Expectations” on each of its three gate­ways.2,3,4 EdReports “reviews mate­rials as they’re designed, not as imple­mented”.5 A rating of design does not say which opening teaches chil­dren more, and EdReports does not claim that it does.

Who chose the book

In Arizona the answer is in statute. A school district’s gov­erning board must “select all text­books used in the common schools.” The meet­ings of any com­mittee it sets up to review text­books must be open to the public. A copy of each text­book under con­sid­er­a­tion must sit at the dis­trict office for public review “for a period of sixty days prior to formal selec­tion”.23 So while an Arizona dis­trict is choosing a new grade 5 book, a parent can open each can­di­date to this lesson. Charter schools are exempt from this statute.

In 19 states a state-appointed board reviews text­books first and lists those that dis­tricts may con­sider, and the rules vary from state to state.24 In the rest, dis­tricts are largely left to choose for themselves.

Neither kind of board has much evi­dence of effect to go on. Morgan Polikoff and Jake Rowley wrote in Education Next in November 2026 about the evi­dence for cur­ricula. The past decade, they say, “has pro­duced van­ish­ingly little evi­dence on which cur­ricula truly work best.” Their example is a review of 36 studies of K–5 reading curricula.22

A parent or a board member can still ask three things of the grade 5 book. Before anyone com­putes, does the first lesson on unlike denom­i­na­tors ask where the sum must land? The standard’s own example does.1 Who makes the first mark, and if the chil­dren do, does the teacher’s guide build the expla­na­tion on their attempts? What is asked a week later, on a sum the child has not seen? These ques­tions are not a buying guide. My own books would have to answer every one of them, and none of the answers would show which order teaches children more.

The closest experiment used pizza

Experiments on the order of a lesson exist, though none on this sum. In a German class­room study led by Claudia Mazziotti, fifth graders had to decide whether two groups sharing pizzas received the same amount per person. It is a close cousin of the strip problem. Both require a child to see two frac­tions on a common scale. The pizza ques­tion asks about equiv­a­lence. The strip also asks the child to join two lengths.8

Across nine classes in three schools, 228 chil­dren aged ten to twelve took part. Classes, not chil­dren, were ran­domly assigned to one of four con­di­tions. Some tried the problem before a teacher explained it, some after­wards. Some worked alone, some in pairs. Both orders included about thirty minutes of problem solving and forty-five minutes of instruc­tion. The instructor com­pared typical student solutions with the con­ven­tional one, using exam­ples col­lected earlier so that the demon­stra­tions would be com­pa­rable across classes. The chil­dren had enough pre­req­ui­site knowl­edge, by the researchers’ measure, to get started. One pair sug­gested that the birthday child should receive a whole pizza. Quite a rea­son­able pro­posal for a party. It changed the arith­metic the researchers wanted solved.8

On the sub­se­quent test of frac­tion con­cepts, the researchers detected no advan­tage for starting with the problem. Only nine classes were assigned, and the authors report that their test’s internal con­sis­tency was low. The result still belongs near the front of any honest case for letting the child try. Here were chil­dren of approx­i­mately the right age, working on frac­tions, offered a sub­stan­tial chance to think before teaching. Being able to begin did not guar­antee that begin­ning this way paid off on the test. The study did not use a child’s response to a half-strip ques­tion to choose the next move.8

The purple pen

Three studies from an over­lap­ping group of researchers let younger chil­dren tackle a dif­ferent puzzle. Write 3 + 5 = 4 + □. A child who takes the equals sign as the signal to supply a total may put 8 in the box. A child who adds every visible number gets 12. The answer is 4. Each side must name the same number. This is a useful coun­ter­part to the frac­tion problem because the wrong answers have reasons an adult can recognize.25,26,27

Marci DeCaro and Bethany Rittle-Johnson ran­domly assigned 159 chil­dren in grades two through four to indi­vidual lessons. Children who tried the equa­tions before instruc­tion aver­aged 67% on con­cep­tual ques­tions, com­pared with 60% for those taught first, across the imme­diate and two-week assess­ments. No matching pro­ce­dural advan­tage appeared. Neither age nor mea­sured prior knowl­edge reli­ably changed the effect of the order in this sample, which excluded high pretest scorers. That one exploratory test counts, weakly, against a broad claim that a teacher can choose the better order from what a child already knows.25

Emily Fyfe and col­leagues obtained a dif­ferent result with 122 second and third graders. Their lessons pro­vided feed­back and asked chil­dren to explain correct solutions. Children taught first did better on pro­ce­dures, 62% against 49%, and on ques­tions about equa­tion struc­ture, 52% against 43%. The groups did sim­i­larly on the other con­cep­tual measure, knowl­edge of the equals sign. Hearing an expla­na­tion early seems, in this lesson, to have given chil­dren an idea they could use in explaining the next solu­tion. The studies dif­fered in enough respects that no single prompt can account for the reversal with confidence.26

Then came the purple pens. In Abbey Loehr and colleagues’ first class­room exper­i­ment, 41 second graders com­pleted the two phases in dif­ferent orders. The chil­dren who tried first scored lower on con­cep­tual under­standing, 66% against 88%. In a second exper­i­ment with 47 second graders, every child even­tu­ally received a purple pen and the orig­inal work. The child checked an answer or wrote a revi­sion above it. This time the chil­dren who had tried first did better on sub­se­quent problem solving, with com­pa­rable con­cep­tual scores.27 The exper­i­ments dif­fered in other ways too. The pens make a mem­o­rable detail because they ren­dered visible a part of the lesson that is easy to omit. Once chil­dren have some­thing better to think with, do they ever see their first answer again?

On the frac­tion page I would leave 2/5 unerased. After the sixths have been drawn, give the child a dif­ferent pencil and ask for one mark showing where the old answer would have landed. Now the reason to change the answer belongs to the child.

What the average leaves out

Tanmay Sinha and Manu Kapur com­bined 53 studies yielding 166 com­par­isons of problem solving before and after instruc­tion. Kapur is the researcher who devel­oped pro­duc­tive failure, so the review weighs one of its authors’ own ideas. Across ages and sub­jects, attempting first had an average advan­tage of 0.36 stan­dard devi­a­tions on con­cep­tual under­standing and transfer to other prob­lems (95% con­fi­dence interval, 0.20 to 0.51). On pro­ce­dural out­comes, avail­able in 51 com­par­isons, the esti­mate was −0.03 (interval, −0.20 to 0.15). If the test asks whether a student can carry out a taught pro­ce­dure, the review found no reli­able advan­tage for either order. Only 75 of the 166 com­par­isons were in math­e­matics. The review’s own summary adds that for second to fifth graders the effects favored instruc­tion first. Its esti­mate for the randomized com­par­isons alone was 0.25 (interval, 0.04 to 0.47).9

An average also hides how the lessons inside it were built. An earlier review by Katharina Loibl, Ido Roll and Nikol Rummel finds that trying first fosters learning only in lessons with par­tic­ular design fea­tures. It names two, con­trasting cases and instruc­tion built on the students’ own solutions.28 Loibl and Rummel are also among the authors of the pizza study. The purple pen does this in small, and so does leaving 2/5 on the page.

That review gives a way to read the three text­books. The Illustrative Mathematics notes describe the kind of try-first lesson it sup­ports, with the dis­cus­sion built on strate­gies the teacher gathers from the chil­dren. Savvas’s 2020 handout tells the teacher to have stu­dents share their work and discuss each other’s ideas, with the publisher’s sample student work as another option.20 The handout for the pre­vious edition sug­gests dis­playing correct and incor­rect strate­gies. It says teachers “iden­tify strate­gies that they want stu­dents to share with the whole group.” The second step, it says, “con­nects the students’ thinking and solutions” to the lesson’s ideas.21 The expla­na­tion that follows is a pre­pared, com­pleted problem. Whether it is taught from the class’s own attempts cannot be seen from the handouts.

The case for showing first

The case for showing first does not depend on a child’s bad history. Paul Kirschner, John Sweller and Richard Clark set it out in 2006. A learner without the method has to search for it. Such a search, they write, “can func­tion per­fectly with no learning what­so­ever.” A worked example removes the search and points atten­tion at the moves that matter. Problem solving becomes the better use of time only “when learners are suf­fi­ciently expe­ri­enced” that a worked example has become redun­dant. They call this the exper­tise reversal effect.29 On that reading my check sits in the wrong place. It tests a pre­req­ui­site, the size of a half. The lesson teaches the common unit, and a child who can find the half has not yet met one. For this lesson that child is still a novice.

For a child who has spent several lessons guessing at frac­tions, the next invi­ta­tion to guess has a history. Showing a half laid neatly across three sixths can restore the pos­si­bility of a con­ver­sa­tion. Both people can point to pre­cisely what they are talking about. A teacher who knows that history has a good reason to start there.

The strongest exper­i­ment on that side has nothing to do with frac­tions. Greg Ashman, Slava Kalyuga and John Sweller ran two fully randomized exper­i­ments with Year 5 primary stu­dents learning about the energy effi­ciency of light. In the first, with 64 stu­dents, those taught explic­itly before solving prob­lems did better on prob­lems like the ones in the lesson, with no dif­fer­ence on transfer prob­lems. In the second, with 71 stu­dents and harder mate­rial, they did better on both. The authors con­clude that when a topic has many inter­acting parts, “explicit instruc­tion should precede problem-solving”.30 Sweller devel­oped cog­ni­tive load theory, which pre­dicts the result.

The Sinha and Kapur review’s youngest sub­group, grades two through five, deserves par­tic­ular care. The sub­group table prints an esti­mate of −0.09 with an interval of −0.92 to −0.16. The esti­mate falls outside its own interval. Four of the other ten rows of the review’s Table 4 have the same defect. Both the table and the dis­cus­sion point toward showing first for this group, but those figures cannot estab­lish a trust­worthy mag­ni­tude or degree of cer­tainty. The authors them­selves write that younger stu­dents “seemed to benefit” from instruc­tion first, though in 18 of the 25 com­par­isons the chil­dren had pro­duced several solutions of their own. Nor were chil­dren ran­domly assigned to ages. Older and younger groups studied dif­ferent mate­rial in dif­ferent set­tings. The evi­dence offers no age cutoff a teacher could respon­sibly use. The review includes some of the studies dis­cussed here, so its average and the indi­vidual exper­i­ments are partly the same evidence.9

Substantial evi­dence sits on the other side of the teaching deci­sion. Christina Barbieri and col­leagues syn­the­sized 55 studies, span­ning ele­men­tary through post­sec­ondary math­e­matics, on learning with worked exam­ples. The average effect on math­e­matics per­for­mance favored exam­ples by 0.48 stan­dard devi­a­tions. This is a dif­ferent com­par­ison. An exper­i­ment can show that studying a solved example beats solving the same prob­lems without one. It does not settle whether a child should get a first look at one problem before seeing that example. Comparing 0.48 with 0.36 as if the larger number won would man­u­fac­ture an answer neither review estimated.31

The strongest evi­dence for explicit teaching comes from chil­dren who struggle with math­e­matics. Madhavi Jayanthi and col­leagues ran­domly assigned 205 fifth graders expe­ri­encing math­e­matics dif­fi­cul­ties to a small-group frac­tions inter­ven­tion or usual instruc­tion. The inter­ven­tion com­bined sys­tem­atic teaching, rods and number lines, with a focus on explaining solutions. Reported effects favored the inter­ven­tion on pro­ce­dures (1.07 stan­dard devi­a­tions) and on frac­tion pro­fi­ciency and under­standing (0.66 to 0.78). The What Works Clearinghouse rated the 2018 tech­nical report on the same trial, which ana­lyzed 186 stu­dents, as meeting its design stan­dards without reser­va­tions. This was sus­tained teaching over months. The result gives a teacher reason to demon­strate and ask for expla­na­tions with con­fi­dence. It cannot show what pro­por­tion of the gain came from the order of the first two minutes.32,33

A trial pub­lished in 2026 by Robin Schumacher and col­leagues makes the dis­tinc­tion espe­cially clear. Ninety-nine fifth graders with math­e­matics dif­fi­cul­ties were ran­domly assigned to usual teaching or 36 lessons over twelve weeks. Children in the inter­ven­tion exam­ined correct and incor­rect worked solutions and explained what the steps meant. They out­per­formed the com­par­ison group on verbal and written expla­na­tions (effects of 0.89 to 1.11 stan­dard devi­a­tions), as well as on frac­tion pro­fi­ciency. A child who has seen a method can still have a great deal of math­e­mat­ical thinking left to do. The exper­i­ment tested the full program, and did not isolate either the worked exam­ples or their timing.34

A review by Sarah Krowka and col­leagues found an average benefit of 0.68 stan­dard devi­a­tions across 28 rational-number inter­ven­tion studies involving U.S. stu­dents with math­e­matics dif­fi­cul­ties in grades three through nine. The 95% con­fi­dence interval for that average was 0.51 to 0.85. The pre­dic­tion interval, which describes the much greater uncer­tainty about an effect in a new setting, stretched from −0.36 to 1.8. Programs that used number lines or taught math­e­mat­ical lan­guage tended to show larger gains in adjusted analyses. Those fea­tures trav­eled with other fea­tures of good teaching. Several review authors also wrote the fifth-grade trials or served on the federal inter­ven­tion guide. Taken together, the work sup­ports giving strug­gling stu­dents coherent instruc­tion and a shared vocab­u­lary. It sup­plies no timetable for how long any one child should struggle.35,36

Two more federal guides lean the same way. A 2007 guide recommends, on evi­dence it rates mod­erate, that stu­dents alter­nate between worked solutions and prob­lems of their own.37 The 2021 inter­ven­tion guide rates the evi­dence for sys­tem­atic instruc­tion strong, and describes worked exam­ples from which steps are left out for the child to supply.36

Showing first saves time and spares a child one more failure. Its cost is that the teacher never sees what the child would have tried, and a child who could have found the sixths is handed them.

My answer stands in part, and the rule at its center is not the part. The opening ques­tion stands. It takes under a minute, and the stan­dard already prints its check. Leaving the next piece to the child stands too. If I show too soon, the child still has the third to place, and the 2021 guide’s worked example with a step left out is the same move. The rule between those two does not stand as an answer. Nothing above shows that a child who can use the half learns more by making the next mark before seeing the common unit. For chil­dren of this age the exper­i­ments lean the other way, though DeCaro’s and Loehr’s second exper­i­ment did not, and the one fifth-grade frac­tion study found no dif­fer­ence. Ashman’s, Fyfe’s and Loehr’s chil­dren were not chosen for dif­fi­culty, and many of them would have passed my check. Waiting has a price as well. In Loehr’s first class, the chil­dren who tried first and were taught after­ward scored 22 points lower on con­cepts than those taught first. So I hold the rule as a hypoth­esis for a trial. Until one is run, a teacher who shows the common unit first and hands back the pencil is on firmer ground than I am when I wait.

Check

I would judge my own page by what the child can do after it closes. Here are three ques­tions I would keep for another day, without the orig­inal picture in view.

Will two thirds plus three quar­ters pass one? Each is more than half, so the sum must pass one. Now find the end­point. Eight twelfths and nine twelfths give sev­en­teen twelfths, five twelfths beyond one. A child who pre­dicts the crossing and then makes an arith­metic slip has shown the teacher exactly where to look.

Will eighths do for three quar­ters plus one eighth? Six eighths and one eighth make seven eighths. Thirty-seconds would also do. Ask the child to show why twenty-eight thirty-seconds ends at the same point. This time mul­ti­plying the two denom­i­na­tors pro­duces much more work than the sum needs. The choice tests whether the child knows what a common unit is for.

Half a meter of ribbon is joined to a third of a meter. A friend says the length is four fifths of a meter. Could that be right? Four fifths passes the first test. It is longer than a half and shorter than one. To settle it, compare the pro­posed length with five sixths. In thir­ti­eths they are 24 and 25. The dif­fer­ence is just one thir­tieth of a meter. The opening ques­tion was pow­erful enough to catch an impos­sible answer. Here the child dis­covers why an answer that looks rea­son­able still needs a proof.

A number line can become a routine as readily as a rule can. Sevim Nuraydin and col­leagues ran­domly assigned 188 stu­dents in grades five through eight to ver­sions of a frac­tion number-line game or an active com­par­ison. The younger stu­dents improved on the kind of zero-to-one line they had prac­ticed. The gain did not carry to a zero-to-five line, frac­tion com­par­ison, or frac­tion arith­metic. The game sup­plied feed­back and omitted direct instruc­tion.38 Even a teacher with no inten­tion of using a screen can take a lesson from this. Try the same ques­tion on a line with a dif­ferent end­point. A child who has learned a posi­tion on the page can put a half in the middle of a zero-to-five line. A child who checks the unit will put it between zero and one.

The same caution applies to my own pref­er­ence for teaching the reason. In a pre­reg­is­tered exper­i­ment with 156 stu­dents in grades six through nine, D. W. Braithwaite and G. J. Hall gave explicit instruc­tion in frac­tion arith­metic. Varying whether stu­dents heard ratio­nales for pro­ce­dures, or whether prac­tice alter­nated dif­ferent pro­ce­dures, pro­duced no detectable extra gain in pro­ce­dural accu­racy. The stu­dents were older, and the outcome was cal­cu­la­tion. The result has a con­se­quence for anyone writing this kind of lesson. Printing an excel­lent reason is an accom­plish­ment for the author. Finding out whether the reader can use it requires a fresh problem.39

In deciding whether to keep this way of teaching, I would also want a test the page could fail. Before assigning class­rooms to the two open­ings, record what chil­dren can do with a fixed whole and a bench­mark. Give both groups the same worked expla­na­tion, prac­tice time and oppor­tu­nity to revise. Score a fresh problem after a delay, with the scorer unaware of the lesson order. The telling com­par­ison would be whether the benefit of attempting first differs with the starting knowl­edge that was mea­sured. If chil­dren who show the bench­mark gain just as much from seeing the method imme­di­ately, the case for making them wait grows weaker. If chil­dren who ini­tially miss it benefit from trying first, the gate is too narrow. No study found for this essay tested that par­tic­ular decision rule.

The evi­dence against me begins with Ashman’s two exper­i­ments and the results for younger chil­dren in Fyfe’s study and Loehr’s first class. Sinha and Kapur read their own youngest group the same way, and DeCaro’s test found no effect of prior knowl­edge. The arith­metic is certain, and the opening ques­tion is printed in a stan­dard and a federal guide. The rule that follows it rests on rea­soning from the strip and on no trial, and it is the part I hold loosely.

The rule is for one child at a table, and for a class it offers only a look at every child’s first mark. The com­par­ison of pro­grams has gaps. The enVision teacher’s edition was not seen. Of Eureka, one lesson and the module over­view were read, in the EngageNY text of 2013 and 2014. EdReports rated the 2015 edition of Eureka, and the 2021 Illustrative Mathematics in another distributor’s edition. No figure for how many class­rooms use each program was found, so nothing here ranks the pro­grams by reach. The 1980 article that first pub­lished the 1978 item was not retrieved, and no later national result on adding frac­tions was found. The Ashman, Loibl and Barbieri papers were read in abstract only. No pub­lisher was asked to comment before pub­li­ca­tion, and a factual error that any of them shows will be cor­rected here with a dated note.

What I would keep from the first moment at the table is modest. The child wrote two fifths. Before the teacher said “sixths,” there was already one fact the child could own. The finger had to move to the right.

A related ques­tion arises when a school offers eighth-grade algebra. Where will stu­dents learn the math­e­matics the dis­placed course was meant to teach?

Sources

  1. Common Core State Standards Initiative. Common Core State Standards for Mathematics, 2010. See 3.NF.3d, the footnote to the grade 4 fraction standards, and 5.NF.1 and 5.NF.2. Standards. ↑
  2. EdReports. Imagine Learning Illustrative Mathematics K–5 Math (2021). Review. ↑
  3. EdReports. Eureka Math (2015). Review. ↑
  4. EdReports. enVision Mathematics Common Core (2024), fifth grade. Source of the ratings and of the quoted passages from Lessons 7-1 and 7-3. Review. ↑
  5. EdReports. Q&A: Evidence and efficacy in curriculum adoption. Interview with Eric Hirsch, executive director, April 23, 2024. Article. ↑
  6. Hugues Lortie-Forgues, Jing Tian and Robert S. Siegler. Why Is Learning Fraction and Decimal Arithmetic So Difficult? Developmental Review, 2015. Research review, read in the authors’ manuscript. It reports the 1978 assessment item from T. P. Carpenter and colleagues, Mathematics Teacher, 1980, which was not retrieved. Review. ↑
  7. Sabrina M. Di Lonardo Burr and colleagues. Finding their way: Students’ fraction misconceptions and errors over two years of fraction learning. Learning and Instruction 106, 102454, 2026. Published online August 6, 2026. Four-wave longitudinal study. ↑
  8. Claudia Mazziotti, Nikol Rummel, Anne Deiglmayr and Katharina Loibl. Probing boundary conditions of Productive Failure and analyzing the role of young students’ collaboration. npj Science of Learning, 2019. Fifth-grade classroom quasi-experiment. ↑
  9. Tanmay Sinha and Manu Kapur. When Problem Solving Followed by Instruction Works: Evidence for Productive Failure. Review of Educational Research, 2021. See the pooled effects and the grade-level row of Table 4. Meta-analysis. ↑
  10. Robert S. Siegler and Hugues Lortie-Forgues. Hard Lessons: Why Rational Number Arithmetic Is So Difficult for So Many People. Current Directions in Psychological Science 26(4), 346–351, 2017. Read in the accepted version. Article. ↑
  11. Igor Barani. Why should a new idea in mathematics start with a problem a child cannot yet solve? November 5, 2026. Earlier note. ↑
  12. Arizona Department of Education. Arizona Mathematics Standards, 5th Grade. Adopted December 2016, updated January 2025. See 5.NF.A.1 and 5.NF.A.2. Standards. ↑
  13. Robert Siegler and colleagues. Developing Effective Fractions Instruction for Kindergarten Through 8th Grade. Institute of Education Sciences, 2010. See recommendations 2 and 3. Practice guide. ↑
  14. Illustrative Mathematics. IM K–5 Math, Grade 5, Unit 6, Lesson 8, Add and Subtract Fractions. Preparation and lesson pages, read November 19, 2026. Preparation page and lesson page. ↑
  15. Illustrative Mathematics. IM K–5 Math, Grade 5, Unit 6, Lesson 9. Read November 19, 2026. Teacher page. ↑
  16. Illustrative Mathematics. IM K–5 Math, Grade 5, Unit 6, Lesson 10. Read November 19, 2026. Teacher page. ↑
  17. Illustrative Mathematics. IM K–5 Math, Grade 5, Unit 6, Lesson 12. Read November 19, 2026. Teacher page. ↑
  18. New York State Common Core Mathematics Curriculum (EngageNY), Grade 5, Module 3, Lesson 3, 2013, as reproduced with annotations by Achieve the Core, 2015. Lesson. ↑
  19. New York State Common Core Mathematics Curriculum (EngageNY), Grade 5, Module 3, Module Overview, 2014, as hosted by UnboundEd. See Topic D, Lessons 13 and 15. Overview. ↑
  20. Savvas Learning Company. enVision Mathematics © 2020, Teaching a Lesson. Training handout. Handout. ↑
  21. Savvas Learning Company. enVisionmath2.0 © 2017, Problem-Based Learning. Training handout for the previous edition, 2020. Handout. ↑
  22. Morgan Polikoff and Jake Rowley. The Myth of the Evidence-Based Curriculum. Education Next, November 12, 2026. Feature article. It describes a review of 36 studies of K–5 English language arts curricula. Article. ↑
  23. Arizona Revised Statutes §15-721, subsection F, paragraphs 1 to 3. For the exemption of charter schools, see §15-183, subsection E, paragraph 5. Statute and charter schools. ↑
  24. Sy Doan and Julia Kaufman. What Role Do States Play in Selecting K-12 Textbooks? The State Education Standard 24(1), National Association of State Boards of Education, January 2024. Article. ↑
  25. Marci S. DeCaro and Bethany Rittle-Johnson. Exploring mathematics problems prepares children to learn from instruction. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2012. Individual tutoring experiment. ↑
  26. Emily R. Fyfe, Marci S. DeCaro and Bethany Rittle-Johnson. An alternative time for telling: When conceptual instruction prior to problem solving improves mathematical knowledge. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 2014. Individual tutoring experiment. ↑
  27. Abbey M. Loehr, Emily R. Fyfe and Bethany Rittle-Johnson. Wait for it . . . Delaying instruction improves mathematics problem solving: A classroom study. The Journal of Problem Solving, 2014. Two second-grade experiments. ↑
  28. Katharina Loibl, Ido Roll and Nikol Rummel. Towards a Theory of When and How Problem Solving Followed by Instruction Supports Learning. Educational Psychology Review 29, 693–715, 2017. Read in abstract. Review. ↑
  29. Paul A. Kirschner, John Sweller and Richard E. Clark. Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based Teaching. Educational Psychologist 41(2), 75–86, 2006. Article. ↑
  30. Greg Ashman, Slava Kalyuga and John Sweller. Problem-solving or Explicit Instruction: Which Should Go First When Element Interactivity Is High? Educational Psychology Review 32, 2020. Read in abstract. Two randomized experiments. ↑
  31. Christina A. Barbieri, Dana Miller-Cotto, Sarah N. Clerjuste and Kamal Chawla. A meta-analysis of the worked examples effect on mathematics performance. Educational Psychology Review, 2023. Read in abstract. Meta-analysis. ↑
  32. Madhavi Jayanthi and colleagues. Improving Struggling Fifth-Grade Students’ Understanding of Fractions: A Randomized Controlled Trial of an Intervention That Stresses Both Concepts and Procedures. Exceptional Children, 2021. Randomized trial. ↑
  33. What Works Clearinghouse. Review of “Impact of a Tier 2 Fractions Intervention on Fifth-Grade Students’ Fractions Achievement: A Technical Report.” Institute of Education Sciences, reviewed November 2019. Study review. ↑
  34. Robin F. Schumacher and colleagues. Using Worked Examples to Enhance Students’ Mathematical Explanations during Fractions Intervention. The Elementary School Journal, 2026. Randomized trial, 36 lessons. ↑
  35. Sarah K. Krowka and colleagues. Identifying key instructional practices in rational number interventions: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Learning Disability Quarterly 48(4), 2025. Published online 2024. Meta-analysis. ↑
  36. Lynn S. Fuchs and colleagues. Assisting Students Struggling with Mathematics: Intervention in the Elementary Grades (WWC 2021006). What Works Clearinghouse, Institute of Education Sciences, 2021. Practice guide. ↑
  37. Harold Pashler and colleagues. Organizing Instruction and Study to Improve Student Learning (NCER 2007-2004). Institute of Education Sciences, 2007. See recommendation 2. Practice guide. ↑
  38. Sevim Nuraydin, Johannes Stricker and Michael Schneider. No transfer effect of a fraction number line game on fraction understanding or fraction arithmetic: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2022. Randomized trial. ↑
  39. D. W. Braithwaite and G. J. Hall. Explaining procedures and interleaving practice in fraction arithmetic. Learning and Instruction 90, 101854, 2024. Preregistered experiment. ↑

In this series

All writing